|
Post by AeroCooper on Feb 13, 2017 5:47:20 GMT -5
Adam's Apple 12 Back In the Saddle 12 Big Ten Inch Record 5 Cheese Cake 12 +1 Chip Away the Stone 11 Chiquita 10 Critical Mass 6 Draw the Line 12 Dream On 7 Get the Lead Out 11 +1 Home Tonight 12 I Wanna Know Why 7 Kings and Queens 12 Last Child 10 Lick and a Promise 12 Lord of the Thighs 14 Make It 12 Mama Kin 10 Mia 18 Milkcow Blues 11 Mother Popcorn 7 No More No More 10 No Surprise 10 Nobody's Fault 35 -2 One Way Street 9 Pandora's Box 11 Rats In the Cellar 16 Remember (Walking in the Sand) 7 Round and Round 4 S.O.S. (Too Bad) 13 Same Old Song and Dance 10 Seasons of Wither 18 Sick as a Dog 25 Sight for Sore Eyes 10 Somebody 9 -1 Spaced 11 Sweet Emotion 20 Think About It 7 Uncle Salty 11 Walkin' the Dog 10 Woman of the World 30 You See Me Crying 13
Eliminated songs (in order of elimination, with first eliminated listed last) 43. Toys In The Attic 44. Bright Light Fright 45. Reefer Head Woman 46. Combination 47. Rattlesnake Shake 48. Write Me 49. Helter Skelter 50. Bone to Bone (Coney Island White Fish Boy) 51. Movin' Out 52. Train Kept A' Rollin' 53. Get It Up 54. Three Mile Smile 55. Major Barbra 56. Walk This Way 57. All Your Love 58. The Hand That Feeds 59: Come Together
|
|
|
Post by anaix3l on Feb 13, 2017 6:24:40 GMT -5
Adam's Apple 12 Back In the Saddle 12 Big Ten Inch Record 5 Cheese Cake 12 Chip Away the Stone 11 Chiquita 10 Critical Mass 6 Draw the Line 12 Dream On 7 Get the Lead Out 11 Home Tonight 12 I Wanna Know Why 7 Kings and Queens 12 Last Child 10 Lick and a Promise 12 Lord of the Thighs 14 Make It 12 Mama Kin 10 Mia 18 Milkcow Blues 11 Mother Popcorn 7 No More No More 10 No Surprise 10 Nobody's Fault 35 One Way Street 9 Pandora's Box 11 Rats In the Cellar 16 Remember (Walking in the Sand) 7 Round and Round 1 -3 S.O.S. (Too Bad) 13 Same Old Song and Dance 10 Seasons of Wither 18 Sick as a Dog 27 +2 Sight for Sore Eyes 10 Somebody 9 Spaced 11 Sweet Emotion 20 Think About It 7 Uncle Salty 11 Walkin' the Dog 10 Woman of the World 30 You See Me Crying 13
Eliminated songs (in order of elimination, with first eliminated listed last) 43. Toys In The Attic 44. Bright Light Fright 45. Reefer Head Woman 46. Combination 47. Rattlesnake Shake 48. Write Me 49. Helter Skelter 50. Bone to Bone (Coney Island White Fish Boy) 51. Movin' Out 52. Train Kept A' Rollin' 53. Get It Up 54. Three Mile Smile 55. Major Barbra 56. Walk This Way 57. All Your Love 58. The Hand That Feeds 59: Come Together
|
|
|
Post by black911 on Feb 13, 2017 8:43:52 GMT -5
Adam's Apple 12 Back In the Saddle 12 Big Ten Inch Record 2 -3 Cheese Cake 12 Chip Away the Stone 11 Chiquita 10 Critical Mass 6 Draw the Line 12 Dream On 7 Get the Lead Out 11 Home Tonight 12 I Wanna Know Why 7 Kings and Queens 12 Last Child 10 Lick and a Promise 12 Lord of the Thighs 14 Make It 12 Mama Kin 10 Mia 18 Milkcow Blues 11 Mother Popcorn 7 No More No More 10 No Surprise 10 Nobody's Fault 35 One Way Street 9 Pandora's Box 11 Rats In the Cellar 16 Remember (Walking in the Sand) 7 Round and Round 1 S.O.S. (Too Bad) 13 Same Old Song and Dance 10 Seasons of Wither 18 Sick as a Dog 27 Sight for Sore Eyes 10 Somebody 9 Spaced 11 Sweet Emotion 20 Think About It 7 Uncle Salty 11 Walkin' the Dog 10 Woman of the World 32 +2 You See Me Crying 13
Eliminated songs (in order of elimination, with first eliminated listed last) 43. Toys In The Attic 44. Bright Light Fright 45. Reefer Head Woman 46. Combination 47. Rattlesnake Shake 48. Write Me 49. Helter Skelter 50. Bone to Bone (Coney Island White Fish Boy) 51. Movin' Out 52. Train Kept A' Rollin' 53. Get It Up 54. Three Mile Smile 55. Major Barbra 56. Walk This Way 57. All Your Love 58. The Hand That Feeds 59: Come Together
|
|
|
Post by aerozhul on Feb 13, 2017 9:18:23 GMT -5
To clarify, Ruts is f'ing amazing. My comment was meant to say that I don't consider THTF and Get it Up weak in any way. I love the opening riffs on Get it Up. They rock. It's just the song then becomes lyrically lazy after that. Couldn't agree more, that song had so much potential but went downhill fast.
|
|
|
Post by aerozhul on Feb 13, 2017 9:21:11 GMT -5
Adam's Apple 12 Back In the Saddle 12 Big Ten Inch Record 2 Cheese Cake 12 Chip Away the Stone 11 Chiquita 10 Critical Mass 3 -3 Draw the Line 12 Dream On 7 Get the Lead Out 11 Home Tonight 12 I Wanna Know Why 7 Kings and Queens 12 Last Child 10 Lick and a Promise 12 Lord of the Thighs 14 Make It 12 Mama Kin 10 Mia 18 Milkcow Blues 11 Mother Popcorn 7 No More No More 10 No Surprise 10 Nobody's Fault 35 One Way Street 9 Pandora's Box 11 Rats In the Cellar 16 Remember (Walking in the Sand) 7 Round and Round 1 S.O.S. (Too Bad) 13 Same Old Song and Dance 10 Seasons of Wither 20 +2 Sick as a Dog 27 Sight for Sore Eyes 10 Somebody 9 Spaced 11 Sweet Emotion 20 Think About It 7 Uncle Salty 11 Walkin' the Dog 10 Woman of the World 32 You See Me Crying 13
Eliminated songs (in order of elimination, with first eliminated listed last) 43. Toys In The Attic 44. Bright Light Fright 45. Reefer Head Woman 46. Combination 47. Rattlesnake Shake 48. Write Me 49. Helter Skelter 50. Bone to Bone (Coney Island White Fish Boy) 51. Movin' Out 52. Train Kept A' Rollin' 53. Get It Up 54. Three Mile Smile 55. Major Barbra 56. Walk This Way 57. All Your Love 58. The Hand That Feeds 59: Come Together
|
|
|
Post by bartman2001 on Feb 13, 2017 9:41:28 GMT -5
Adam's Apple 12 Back In the Saddle 12 Big Ten Inch Record 2 Cheese Cake 12 Chip Away the Stone 11 Chiquita 10 Critical Mass 3 Draw the Line 12 Dream On 4 -3 Get the Lead Out 11 Home Tonight 12 I Wanna Know Why 7 Kings and Queens 12 Last Child 10 Lick and a Promise 12 Lord of the Thighs 14 Make It 12 Mama Kin 10 Mia 18 Milkcow Blues 11 Mother Popcorn 7 No More No More 10 No Surprise 10 Nobody's Fault 37 +2 One Way Street 9 Pandora's Box 11 Rats In the Cellar 16 Remember (Walking in the Sand) 7 Round and Round 1 S.O.S. (Too Bad) 13 Same Old Song and Dance 10 Seasons of Wither 20 Sick as a Dog 27 Sight for Sore Eyes 10 Somebody 9 Spaced 11 Sweet Emotion 20 Think About It 7 Uncle Salty 11 Walkin' the Dog 10 Woman of the World 32 You See Me Crying 13
Eliminated songs (in order of elimination, with first eliminated listed last) 43. Toys In The Attic 44. Bright Light Fright 45. Reefer Head Woman 46. Combination 47. Rattlesnake Shake 48. Write Me 49. Helter Skelter 50. Bone to Bone (Coney Island White Fish Boy) 51. Movin' Out 52. Train Kept A' Rollin' 53. Get It Up 54. Three Mile Smile 55. Major Barbra 56. Walk This Way 57. All Your Love 58. The Hand That Feeds 59: Come Together
|
|
|
Post by black911 on Feb 14, 2017 3:16:23 GMT -5
Adam's Apple 12 Back In the Saddle 12 Big Ten Inch Record 0 -2 Cheese Cake 12 Chip Away the Stone 11 Chiquita 10 Critical Mass 3 Draw the Line 12 Dream On 4 Get the Lead Out 11 Home Tonight 12 I Wanna Know Why 7 Kings and Queens 12 Last Child 10 Lick and a Promise 12 Lord of the Thighs 14 Make It 11 -1 Mama Kin 10 Mia 18 Milkcow Blues 11 Mother Popcorn 7 No More No More 10 No Surprise 10 Nobody's Fault 37 One Way Street 9 Pandora's Box 11 Rats In the Cellar 16 Remember (Walking in the Sand) 7 Round and Round 1 S.O.S. (Too Bad) 13 Same Old Song and Dance 10 Seasons of Wither 20 Sick as a Dog 27 Sight for Sore Eyes 10 Somebody 9 Spaced 11 Sweet Emotion 20 Think About It 7 Uncle Salty 11 Walkin' the Dog 10 Woman of the World 34 +2 You See Me Crying 13
Eliminated songs (in order of elimination, with first eliminated listed last) 43. Toys In The Attic 44. Bright Light Fright 45. Reefer Head Woman 46. Combination 47. Rattlesnake Shake 48. Write Me 49. Helter Skelter 50. Bone to Bone (Coney Island White Fish Boy) 51. Movin' Out 52. Train Kept A' Rollin' 53. Get It Up 54. Three Mile Smile 55. Major Barbra 56. Walk This Way 57. All Your Love 58. The Hand That Feeds 59: Come Together
|
|
|
Post by anaix3l on Feb 14, 2017 5:39:43 GMT -5
Adam's Apple 12 Back In the Saddle 12 Cheese Cake 12 Chip Away the Stone 11 Chiquita 10 Critical Mass 3 Draw the Line 12 Dream On 4 Get the Lead Out 11 Home Tonight 12 I Wanna Know Why 7 Kings and Queens 12 Last Child 10 Lick and a Promise 12 Lord of the Thighs 14 Make It 11 Mama Kin 10 Mia 18 Milkcow Blues 11 Mother Popcorn 7 No More No More 10 No Surprise 10 Nobody's Fault 37 One Way Street 9 Pandora's Box 11 Rats In the Cellar 16 Remember (Walking in the Sand) 5 -2 Round and Round 0 -1 S.O.S. (Too Bad) 13 Same Old Song and Dance 10 Seasons of Wither 20 Sick as a Dog 29 +2 Sight for Sore Eyes 10 Somebody 9 Spaced 11 Sweet Emotion 20 Think About It 7 Uncle Salty 11 Walkin' the Dog 10 Woman of the World 34 You See Me Crying 13
Eliminated songs (in order of elimination, with first eliminated listed last) 41. Round and Round 42. Big Ten Inch Record 43. Toys In The Attic 44. Bright Light Fright 45. Reefer Head Woman 46. Combination 47. Rattlesnake Shake 48. Write Me 49. Helter Skelter 50. Bone to Bone (Coney Island White Fish Boy) 51. Movin' Out 52. Train Kept A' Rollin' 53. Get It Up 54. Three Mile Smile 55. Major Barbra 56. Walk This Way 57. All Your Love 58. The Hand That Feeds 59: Come Together
|
|
|
Post by AeroCooper on Feb 14, 2017 6:23:12 GMT -5
Adam's Apple 12 Back In the Saddle 12 Cheese Cake 12 Chip Away the Stone 11 Chiquita 10 Critical Mass 3 Draw the Line 12 Dream On 4 Get the Lead Out 11 Home Tonight 12 I Wanna Know Why 7 Kings and Queens 12 Last Child 10 Lick and a Promise 12 Lord of the Thighs 14 Make It 11 Mama Kin 10 Mia 18 Milkcow Blues 11 Mother Popcorn 6 -1 No More No More 10 No Surprise 10 Nobody's Fault 36 -1 One Way Street 9 Pandora's Box 11 Rats In the Cellar 16 Remember (Walking in the Sand) 5 S.O.S. (Too Bad) 13 Same Old Song and Dance 9 -1 Seasons of Wither 20 Sick as a Dog 29 Sight for Sore Eyes 10 Somebody 9 Spaced 11 Sweet Emotion 20 Think About It 7 Uncle Salty 11 Walkin' the Dog 10 Woman of the World 35 +1 You See Me Crying 14 +1
Eliminated songs (in order of elimination, with first eliminated listed last) 41. Round and Round 42. Big Ten Inch Record 43. Toys In The Attic 44. Bright Light Fright 45. Reefer Head Woman 46. Combination 47. Rattlesnake Shake 48. Write Me 49. Helter Skelter 50. Bone to Bone (Coney Island White Fish Boy) 51. Movin' Out 52. Train Kept A' Rollin' 53. Get It Up 54. Three Mile Smile 55. Major Barbra 56. Walk This Way 57. All Your Love 58. The Hand That Feeds 59: Come Together
|
|
|
Post by aerozhul on Feb 14, 2017 7:19:32 GMT -5
Adam's Apple 12 Back In the Saddle 12 Cheese Cake 12 Chip Away the Stone 11 Chiquita 10 Critical Mass 0 -3 Draw the Line 12 Dream On 6 +2 Get the Lead Out 11 Home Tonight 12 I Wanna Know Why 7 Kings and Queens 12 Last Child 10 Lick and a Promise 12 Lord of the Thighs 14 Make It 11 Mama Kin 10 Mia 18 Milkcow Blues 11 Mother Popcorn 6 No More No More 10 No Surprise 10 Nobody's Fault 36 One Way Street 9 Pandora's Box 11 Rats In the Cellar 16 Remember (Walking in the Sand) 5 S.O.S. (Too Bad) 13 Same Old Song and Dance 9 Seasons of Wither 20 Sick as a Dog 29 Sight for Sore Eyes 10 Somebody 9 Spaced 11 Sweet Emotion 20 Think About It 7 Uncle Salty 11 Walkin' the Dog 10 Woman of the World 35 You See Me Crying 14
Eliminated songs (in order of elimination, with first eliminated listed last) 40. Critical Mass 41. Round and Round 42. Big Ten Inch Record 43. Toys In The Attic 44. Bright Light Fright 45. Reefer Head Woman 46. Combination 47. Rattlesnake Shake 48. Write Me 49. Helter Skelter 50. Bone to Bone (Coney Island White Fish Boy) 51. Movin' Out 52. Train Kept A' Rollin' 53. Get It Up 54. Three Mile Smile 55. Major Barbra 56. Walk This Way 57. All Your Love 58. The Hand That Feeds 59: Come Together
|
|
|
Post by bartman2001 on Feb 14, 2017 8:13:54 GMT -5
Adam's Apple 12 Back In the Saddle 12 Cheese Cake 12 Chip Away the Stone 11 Chiquita 10 Draw the Line 12 Dream On 3 -3 Get the Lead Out 11 Home Tonight 12 I Wanna Know Why 7 Kings and Queens 12 Last Child 10 Lick and a Promise 12 Lord of the Thighs 14 Make It 11 Mama Kin 10 Mia 18 Milkcow Blues 11 Mother Popcorn 6 No More No More 10 No Surprise 10 Nobody's Fault 38 +2 One Way Street 9 Pandora's Box 11 Rats In the Cellar 16 Remember (Walking in the Sand) 5 S.O.S. (Too Bad) 13 Same Old Song and Dance 9 Seasons of Wither 20 Sick as a Dog 29 Sight for Sore Eyes 10 Somebody 9 Spaced 11 Sweet Emotion 20 Think About It 7 Uncle Salty 11 Walkin' the Dog 10 Woman of the World 35 You See Me Crying 14
Eliminated songs (in order of elimination, with first eliminated listed last) 40. Critical Mass 41. Round and Round 42. Big Ten Inch Record 43. Toys In The Attic 44. Bright Light Fright 45. Reefer Head Woman 46. Combination 47. Rattlesnake Shake 48. Write Me 49. Helter Skelter 50. Bone to Bone (Coney Island White Fish Boy) 51. Movin' Out 52. Train Kept A' Rollin' 53. Get It Up 54. Three Mile Smile 55. Major Barbra 56. Walk This Way 57. All Your Love 58. The Hand That Feeds 59: Come Together
|
|
|
Post by aerozhul on Feb 14, 2017 21:41:22 GMT -5
So I realize this game is subjective and all....but the statement being made right now by Bart and all you disinterested spectators who won't help me save Dream On is that every other song on this list deserves to be Top 38 but Dream On doesn't. I get that some of those songs do deserve that distinction, but you can't tell me that Mother Popcorn (for example) is better than Dream On. Just sayin'....
|
|
|
Post by AeroCooper on Feb 15, 2017 6:18:08 GMT -5
Adam's Apple 12 Back In the Saddle 13 +1 Cheese Cake 12 Chip Away the Stone 11 Chiquita 10 Draw the Line 12 Dream On 3 Get the Lead Out 11 Home Tonight 12 I Wanna Know Why 7 Kings and Queens 12 Last Child 10 Lick and a Promise 12 Lord of the Thighs 14 Make It 11 Mama Kin 10 Mia 18 Milkcow Blues 10 -1 Mother Popcorn 6 No More No More 10 No Surprise 10 Nobody's Fault 38 One Way Street 8 -1 Pandora's Box 11 Rats In the Cellar 16 Remember (Walking in the Sand) 5 S.O.S. (Too Bad) 13 Same Old Song and Dance 8 -1 Seasons of Wither 20 Sick as a Dog 29 Sight for Sore Eyes 10 Somebody 9 Spaced 11 Sweet Emotion 20 Think About It 7 Uncle Salty 11 Walkin' the Dog 10 Woman of the World 35 You See Me Crying 15 +1
Eliminated songs (in order of elimination, with first eliminated listed last) 40. Critical Mass 41. Round and Round 42. Big Ten Inch Record 43. Toys In The Attic 44. Bright Light Fright 45. Reefer Head Woman 46. Combination 47. Rattlesnake Shake 48. Write Me 49. Helter Skelter 50. Bone to Bone (Coney Island White Fish Boy) 51. Movin' Out 52. Train Kept A' Rollin' 53. Get It Up 54. Three Mile Smile 55. Major Barbra 56. Walk This Way 57. All Your Love 58. The Hand That Feeds 59: Come Together
|
|
|
Post by AeroCooper on Feb 15, 2017 6:34:05 GMT -5
So I realize this game is subjective and all....but the statement being made right now by Bart and all you disinterested spectators who won't help me save Dream On is that every other song on this list deserves to be Top 38 but Dream On doesn't. I get that some of those songs do deserve that distinction, but you can't tell me that Mother Popcorn (for example) is better than Dream On. Just sayin'.... True, it is subjective, but I 'try' not to play defensively, but instead put my points wherever I am feeling it on any given day. There just aren't enough up/down votes as it is for where I want to place them all, and defending a song that someone is determined to vote out is a losing proposition without help from others. So I get what you're saying, if we teamed up we could save Dream On, but meanwhile another favorite may be taking a beating. The final tally of this game will never show the order of the best songs, but I guess what you would call, the songs these players are most passionate about. To Bart NF will always be #1, but to me it is a pretty good song that I have never once sought out, but also rarely skip, so it falls somewhere around #30. Dream On probably should be in the top 10 'best' songs, but I don't feel passionate enough about it to get it there. Does that make sense? Probably not.
|
|
|
Post by aerozhul on Feb 15, 2017 6:54:37 GMT -5
So I realize this game is subjective and all....but the statement being made right now by Bart and all you disinterested spectators who won't help me save Dream On is that every other song on this list deserves to be Top 38 but Dream On doesn't. I get that some of those songs do deserve that distinction, but you can't tell me that Mother Popcorn (for example) is better than Dream On. Just sayin'... The final tally of this game will never show the order of the best songs, but I guess what you would call, the songs these players are most passionate about. To Bart NF will always be #1, but to me it is a pretty good song that I have never once sought out, but also rarely skip, so it falls somewhere around #30. Dream On probably should be in the top 10 'best' songs, but I don't feel passionate enough about it to get it there. Does that make sense? Probably not. Yeah, it makes sense. And that's what's tough about this - I also get torn between saving songs I like and fortifying my favorites for the long haul.....
|
|